Interactive Tier List Evaluation

Help us rank 21 dashboard designs

Sort dashboards from best to worst, then tell us why. Takes about 5 minutes.

21 dashboards
~5 min
Anonymous

Sort

Drag or click each dashboard into a tier. Rank at least 4 to submit.

Inspect

Click any image to zoom in and look at the details.

Share why

Pick 2 words for your top and bottom picks, then submit.

Evaluation Criteria

Layout & Structure

Is it clean and professional, or basic and crowded?

Colors & Contrast

Are colors harmonious, or jarring with poor contrast?

Charts & Labels

Are charts intuitive and easy to read, or confusing?

Interactivity

Do controls work smoothly, or is layout broken/missing data?

Why this study?

These 21 dashboards were generated by different LLMs using the same Asheville Airbnb dataset. They were built as Shiny for Python and R Shiny apps, using either specialized guidelines (Skills) or standard prompts (Vanilla). Your ranking helps us compare how each approach performs.

Anonymous. You can stop anytime.

Show Challenge Prompt & Dataset Sample
Prompt: "Build a professional-grade Shiny dashboard for the selected dataset with clear summary metrics, well-labeled visualizations, and thoughtful interactions that help users compare important patterns in the data."
Dataset Sample (Airbnb Asheville Short):
Name Property Type Room Type Price Accommodates Reviews Rating Neighborhood
The Owl's Nest Studio Apt Entire guest suite Entire home/apt $99 2 494 5.0 South Asheville
The Artist Retreat~$375 Free Activities Daily Entire home Entire home/apt — 6 16 4.94 Tuxedo Park
"The Birdhouse" Eclectic Mountain Vibes w/ a view Private room in home Private room — 4 67 4.97 South Asheville
Asheville Walkable Modern Haven Entire home Entire home/apt $179 3 0 — Downtown Asheville
Victoria's Cottage in the Paris of the South Entire rental unit Entire home/apt $300 2 69 4.88 Candler
S
A
B
C
D

Unranked Dashboards

21 items left
Click a dashboard to select, then click a tier label row above to place it. Click image to zoom.

Evaluation Complete

Ranks submitted! Here is the breakdown of the models, costs, and developer workflows:

Real-Time Community Rankings

Average tier score (S=5, A=4, B=3, C=2, D=1) based on community submissions:

S Tier Assigned